Claims-Made vs Occurrence Insurance: What Is the Difference?

Business insurance basicsPolicy basicsProfessional liabilityGeneral liabilityDirectors and officersClaims

Quick answer

An occurrence policy typically responds to injury or damage that happens while the policy is in force, even if the claim arrives years later. A claims-made policy typically responds only when the claim is made, and often reported, while the policy is active. Retroactive dates and extended reporting periods decide how well past work stays protected.

Two liability policies can have the same limit, the same insurer and the same premium, and still respond very differently when a claim shows up. The difference is often the policy’s trigger: whether it is written on an occurrence basis or a claims-made basis.

It sounds technical, but the trigger decides which policy year pays a claim, what happens when you switch insurers, and whether you are still protected after you close or sell your business. This guide explains both types in plain language. Every policy is worded differently, so confirm the details for your own coverage with a licensed broker.

Owner of a small Ontario consulting firm reviewing her liability coverage on a laptop at her office desk on an autumn morning

What is an occurrence policy?

An occurrence policy typically covers bodily injury or property damage that happens during the policy period. The date the claim is filed usually does not matter. If a customer was hurt in your shop in 2026, the policy you had in 2026 is generally the one that responds, even if the lawsuit arrives in 2029 and you have long since changed insurers.

That is why many business owners find occurrence coverage easier to understand. Each policy year protects the events of that year. Commercial general liability (CGL) policies are often written this way, although the exact wording varies by insurer.

What is a claims-made policy?

A claims-made policy typically covers claims that are made against you while the policy is in force. Many claims-made policies also require the claim to be reported to the insurer during the policy period or within a short window after it.

Under this approach, the policy that pays is usually the one active when the claim arrives, not the one active when the work was done. Claims-made wording is common on professional liability (E&O), directors and officers and cyber policies. Those risks often involve advice, decisions or data incidents where a problem may not surface until long after the work was done.

How do claims-made and occurrence policies compare?

Question Occurrence policy Claims-made policy
What triggers coverage? Injury or damage that happens during the policy period A claim made (and often reported) during the policy period
Which policy year responds? The year the event happened The year the claim is made
Does past work stay protected after the policy ends? Generally yes, for events during the policy period Usually only with continuous coverage or an extended reporting period
Key dates to check Policy period Policy period, retroactive date and reporting deadlines
Common on Commercial general liability Professional liability, D&O and cyber

The table is a general summary. Some policies blend features of both, so always read the insuring agreement and the declarations page.

Why does the timing of a claim matter so much?

Renovation contractor kneeling to inspect newly installed hardwood flooring in a bright Ontario home after finishing the job

Many claims arrive well after the work that caused them. A renovation can show a hidden defect a few years later. A design or accounting error may only come to light during an audit. A client may not realize a piece of advice cost them money until the next fiscal year.

With occurrence coverage, the question is usually “when did the damage happen?” With claims-made coverage, the question is usually “when was the claim made, and was a policy active then?” If you let a claims-made policy lapse, a claim that arrives later about your past work may have no policy to respond to it, even though you were insured when you did the work.

What is a retroactive date on a claims-made policy?

Many claims-made policies include a retroactive date. Work or wrongful acts that took place before that date are typically excluded, even if the claim is made while the policy is active.

The retroactive date often matches the date you first bought claims-made coverage. Keeping that date unchanged when you renew or move to a new insurer is one of the most important things to discuss with your broker. If a new policy resets the retroactive date to the day it starts, your earlier work may lose protection.

What is an extended reporting period, or tail coverage?

An extended reporting period (ERP) gives you extra time to report claims after a claims-made policy ends, provided the act or work happened while the policy was in force. It is often called tail coverage or run-off coverage.

Several Ontario regulators build this into their insurance rules. For example:

  • The College of Dietitians of Ontario requires members with a claims-made policy to have an extended reporting period of at least two years.
  • The Ontario College of Pharmacists requires a claims-made policy to include an extended reporting period of at least three years.
  • The College of Registered Psychotherapists of Ontario requires inactive registrants who practised in Ontario in the previous two years to keep run-off coverage for at least two years after they last practised.

Contracts can ask for the same thing. The federal government’s standard insurance clause for commercial general liability says that if the policy is written on a claims-made basis, coverage must stay in place for at least 12 months after the contract is completed or terminated.

If you hold a professional licence, check your own regulator’s current requirements, since they differ by profession and change over time.

What should I ask before I renew, switch or retire?

Retiring Ontario accountant packing binders into plain boxes in his office, a time when tail coverage often matters

Most coverage gaps with claims-made policies happen at a change point. Before you renew, move to a new insurer, sell your business or stop practising, ask your broker:

  • Is each of my liability policies claims-made or occurrence? Many businesses have both.
  • What is my retroactive date, and will a new policy keep it? Ask for this in writing when you switch.
  • Does the policy include an extended reporting period? Ask how long it lasts, whether it is automatic or optional, and how to buy it.
  • What are the reporting rules? Some policies require prompt notice of a claim or a circumstance that could lead to one.
  • Do my contracts or my regulator set requirements? Leases, client agreements and licensing bodies may require a specific limit, trigger or reporting period.
  • What happens if I close, merge or retire? Plan for tail coverage before your last policy expires.

It also helps to report incidents early. If you learn about a mistake or an unhappy client, ask your broker how your policy treats a notice of circumstances while the policy is still active.

Which type of policy is better for my business?

Neither is better in every case. Occurrence coverage is often simpler for events like slips, falls and property damage. Claims-made coverage is common, and sometimes the only option offered, for professional advice, management decisions and cyber risk.

What matters most is that your coverage stays continuous. With claims-made policies, that means keeping your retroactive date, renewing on time and arranging an extended reporting period when you stop. A licensed broker can review your existing business insurance policies together and point out where the triggers and dates could leave a gap.

In Ontario, independent general insurance brokers are licensed and regulated by the Registered Insurance Brokers of Ontario (RIBO), which handles broker licensing, conduct and consumer complaints.

Get matched with a licensed Ontario broker

CommercialInsurance.ca is a free referral service, not an insurer or broker. Tell us about your business and the coverage you have now, and we will connect you with a licensed Ontario broker, regulated by RIBO, who follows up within 24 hours to review your policy triggers, retroactive dates and reporting periods.

Frequently asked questions

Is general liability insurance in Ontario usually claims-made or occurrence?

Commercial general liability policies are often written on an occurrence basis, while professional liability, directors and officers and cyber policies are commonly written on a claims-made basis. This is a general pattern, not a rule. Check the declarations page or ask your broker to confirm which trigger your policy uses.

What is a retroactive date?

A retroactive date is a date written into many claims-made policies. Work or wrongful acts that happened before that date are usually not covered, even if the claim is made while the policy is active. Keeping the same retroactive date when you renew or switch insurers helps protect your earlier work.

What is an extended reporting period or tail coverage?

It is a provision on a claims-made policy that gives you extra time to report claims after the policy ends, as long as the work or act happened while the policy was in force. Some Ontario regulatory colleges require one for members with claims-made coverage. Whether it is included, optional or priced separately depends on the policy wording.

Do I need tail coverage if I close my business or retire?

If your liability coverage is claims-made, it is worth asking about. A client could bring a claim about your past work after you stop practising, and without an active policy or an extended reporting period there may be no coverage to respond. Some professional regulators require run-off coverage for a set period after you stop practising.

Can CommercialInsurance.ca tell me which type of policy I have?

No. CommercialInsurance.ca is a free referral service, not an insurer or broker, so it does not review, sell or service policies. The broker or insurer that services your policy can confirm the trigger and dates. If you are shopping for coverage, we can connect you with a licensed Ontario broker.

Sources

This article is general information, not insurance or legal advice. Coverage depends on the policy wording. Speak with a licensed broker or advisor about your situation.

1-416-510-5775Connect Now